The Alberta Court of Appeal recently released a ludicrous decision that has to be illegal. It ruled that requiring an aspirant lawyer to swear an oath to Canada's Head of State was unconstitutional. It also ruled that swearing the oath was discriminatory against another faith.
Whaaaaat??!!
How can swearing an oath to our Head of State be unconstitutional??!! It's right there in the Constitution Act of 1982 that Canada's Head of State is the Monarch, in this case King Charles III! Our Constitution also confirms that Canada is a secular country, so how can one's faith be compromised by swearing it?! By refusing, you're essentially refusing to enforce the law.
When I read that in 'The Globe and Mail', I had to pen a letter. I also had to look into who the chief justice of the Alberta Court of Appeal was.
![]() |
| Here is the letter, published yesterday. |
How outrageous.
Her background is in human rights law, so obviously she took the side of the indignant plaintiff who claimed that swearing such an oath was against his religion and his personal oath, previously sworn to his Sikh god. Wrong. As I always say, you have to pull back the curtain to find out what's going on. Justice Khullar should hang her head in constitutional shame. Frankly, she should resign.
Chris Selley agreed. He wrote in 'The National Post', "Well, who needs some silly old king anyway? He's only the head of state, right? The whole thing is preposterous, all the way down. In essence, the Alberta Court of Appeal has excused a lawyer from pledging allegiance to Canada.
"Well, too bad, you have to swear the oath."
In their mis-guided and illogical ruling they said, "We agree with the chambers judge that, correctly interpreted, the Oath of Allegiance is not directed at the Queen as a person; its object is the rule of lay and the Canadian system of constitutional government."
And then they let him off the hook anyway. Whaaaat?
As I wrote, this must be appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada, where it must be overturned -- unless they've all drunk the Koolaid on that bench too.
_________________________
p.s. As always, this is NOT racism. We are all one race, the Human Race. Everything else is cultural and a result of personal decisions.




